#225) INTRODUCING OUR NEW 5 MINUTE VIDEO: “The Lincoln Lightning Talk”

This isn’t a joke. The Gettysburg Address is your model for powerful narrative structure. Check out our new short video that uses it to help you craft your 2 minute Lightning Talk.


It was a bad time, but still, Lincoln did not open with the problem.

WE KNOW THIS: HONEST ABE HONESTLY NAILED IT

We have a new 5-minute video about the Gettysburg Address (below) that combines history with narrative coaching.

Matthew David and I discuss the new video (below), plus I will be the guest next week on Park Howell’s long-running podcast, “The Business of Story,” to further explore the video.

So, why the Gettysburg Address?

Because it is short, sweet, and pure ABT (And, But, Therefore structure), as I discussed this in my 2015 book, “Houston, We Have A Narrative.”

Yes, the iconic speech is a thing of beauty, but it has much more to offer. Our new 5-minute video shows you 5 hugely important attributes that you need for today’s world in crafting a 2-minute “Lightning Talk.”

They are the following …

1 THE SINGULAR NARRATIVE

If you’re not clear on the power and importance of presenting a single problem (rather than a shopping list), we refer you to Nicholas Kristof’s brilliant, concise article from 2009. Among many points, it brings into focus the overwhelming importance of addressing just one SINGLE over-arching problem. Lincoln did it. So should you.

2 OPEN WITH AGREEMENT

Lincoln didn’t open with his problem by shouting, “WE’RE IN A WAR!” No. He basically said, “We can all agree we’ve got a great country.” Then he introduced the problem.

3 TIME

The most powerful dimension of narrative is time. Lincoln knew this intuitively and thus began his speech 87 years earlier, moved forward through time, then finished by pointing to the future.

4 THE DREAM

Martin Luther King, Jr. of course understood the power of “the dream.” So did Lincoln as his first paragraph points to basically, “the American dream.”

5 ADVANCE THE NARRATIVE

Lincoln didn’t dwell on the problem. No, believe it or not, he was like a TikTok producer of today with a short attention span — he moved right along, on to his THEREFORE.

THEREFORE … to summarize, what you want to do is open with agreement, starting at an early point in time, then present your dream vision, followed by introducing your singular problem, then swiftly move on to addressing what is being done (or should be done) about the problem.

Lincoln knew narrative. You need to, as well.

#224) Equivocation Nightmare: Friday’s Exchange (Hawley vs Verma) is a piece of “disastrous testimony” for the Biomedical Establishment

You can’t do this in front of the American public. Average people do not understand this. You must answer the question.

SIMPLE YES OR NO: Can men get pregnant? Say “Next question” if you’re not going to answer it.

#223) Is the NY Times Trying to Imitate The Onion with this OpEd?

The NY Times published a 2524 word OpEd with dull narrative metrics (3.2%/7) about the need to not be dull in today’s “attention economy.” Kinda funny.

See that orange dot below the green box? That tells you the OpEd was probably pretty hard to follow.

THIS EDITORIAL HAS POOR NARRATIVE STRUCTURE

Where to begin.

First off, most OpEd’s in today’s overly busy world tend to be less than 1,000 words. For some reason, the NY Times chose to publish this piece on Saturday about our attention deficit problems which has 2.5 times that many words. Why?

Second, if we look at the narrative metrics (if you’re not familiar with our two metrics you can bone up on them here) we see two stumbles.

The AF should be around 2.5%. It’s over 3%.

The NI should be over 20. It’s 7.

The former reflects flabbiness of editing, the latter reflects a lack of narrative strength.

Third, look more specifically at the basic opening structure. The conversational ABT structure is basically:

We have a problem, but here’s the problem …

That’s confusing — like a double negative — which academics may love but the general public gets lost.

Specifically, you see it at the start of the third paragraph which opens with, “We definitely have an attention problem, but it’s not just …”

What you want is:

Here’s how we want the world to be, but here’s how it is …

That is how you achieve clear, singular focus.

From there this OpEd sends you off on a journey of, “So what is the main point they are trying to make here?” Which means you’ve lost most people, other than the inner circle who are already deeply connected with the subject matter.

I sent this OpEd to five friends, they all failed to get through it — they found it too “dull,” “unfocused,” “ambling,” in their words. Which might be okay for an essay on sub-prime interest rates, but this was about the need to not get distracted and lose focus.

LEARN FROM A 1940’S FRENCH ACTIVIST?

Lastly, it ends by citing a French activist from the 1940’s telling us why we should learn from her.

Are they aware that the style of mass communication back then was different from today? And if so, how do they propose today’s readers access that material without losing focus and getting bored.

My advice, based on the ABT Narrative Framework we’ve developed and our 15 years of training people in narrative structure is to:

  1. Keep your essay to under 1000 words (no excuses)
  2. Get your AF to right around 2.5%
  3. Get your NI to over 20
  4. Lay out the dream, contradict it, expand out from there, then bring it back into tight ABT structure at the end with realistic modern recommended actions.

Or … given what it is (a boring essay on the need to not be boring) just publish it in The Onion.

#222) Is New Cal Tech President Ray Jayawardhana a “Good Communicator”? Yes, here’s QUANTITATIVE PROOF

Rule #1 of powerful communication is “Don’t TELL me, SHOW me.” The NY Times TOLD us yesterday Dr. Jayawardhana is a good communicator, here are the data that SHOW it.

Jayawardhana (based on his 3 major books) is right there with Crichton (versus your typical poorly communicating scientist who is around the snooze emoji).

 

VOICES HAVE A DISTINCT “NARRATIVE FINGERPRINT”

I’ve spent the past decade researching and establishing the two basic narrative metrics — the AF (AND Frequency) and the NI (Narrative Index). A decade ago, I tried to warn of the communications strength of Donald Trump (nobody listened, fortunately he never amounted to much). Last year I put them to use in detail in Lincoln But Trump.

In the fall our NMS (Narrative Metrics Specialist) Liz Strauss teamed up with our ABT buddy Erik Stengler at SUNY Oneonta to do a study using the two metrics to compare the novels of Douglas Faulkner versus Michael Crichton. We discussed it in our Wednesday ABT Discussion Group. You can see the results in the graph above.

FAULKNER WAS COMPLEX, CRICHTON WAS “HIGHLY ACCESSIBLE”

Asking ChatGPT to describe novelist William Faulkner’s writing style it said, “Faulkner’s style prioritizes emotional truth over narrative clarity.” This is conveyed by his AF scores, which are high.

The average AF score for well edited material is 2.5%. Faulkner’s novels average well over 3.5% reflecting the lack of “narrative clarity” achieved for artistic purposes (not from ineptitude).

A score below 2.5% could be described as exceptional narrative clarity.

This is what characterized Michael Crichton’s writing. He wasn’t trying to create characters with “intense inner conflict, moral ambiguity, and emotional complexity” as Faulkner was. As ChatGPT says, Crichton’s work was designed to, “educate, entertain, and warn simultaneously.”

DR. JAYAWARDHANA COMMUNICATES WITH “NARRATIVE CLARITY”

Yesterday, the New York Times announced astrophysicist Ray Jayawardhana as the new president of Caltech. Using our super-simple ABT-ometer, we calculated the two narrative metrics for three of his most significant books.

So look at Jayawardhana’s metrics in the graph above. Bingo. Right there with Crichton.

And if you’re wondering how good that is, we can assure you that the vast majority of scientists, almost all of whom lack “narrative intuition,” end up in the lower right corner of that graph (sorry, it’s what the data show us, over and over again).

 

#221) Biomedical Clarity: 18 Excellent Five Minute ABT-structured Talks from Emory Univ Med School (and R.I.P. climate)

Our 4th year of running the ABT course (our 43rd round overall) at Emory University in Atlanta produced the best group of talks to date.

Emory University Medical School: An ABT Incubator

 

WHY DO WE KEEP TAKING BACK HEART TRANSPLANTS?

If you want the context and answer to this fascinating question watch the first of the 18 five-minute presentations this year from the medical students and faculty of Emory University Medical School. We worked with them all semester long, shaping these short presentations using the ABT Narrative Template. The end results are excellent. You can view them all here.

PUBLIC HEALTH GETS IT, CLIMATE SCIENCE/ACTIVISM IS UTTERLY HOPELESS

Sorry to be so blunt about this but I’ve given nearly 20 years of my life trying to help the climate community with communication, pretty much all for naught. You want to see what their more-than-a-billion-dollars of effort has amounted to? Just look at the title of this article last week in POLITICO. Someone, somewhere should be ashamed of themselves for such a mess (but they aren’t).

This article last week sadly speaks for itself — a tale of staggering incompetence.

 

#220) Why the ABT is so important: The Definitive Signal-to-Noise Tool for Communication

PROBLEM: The Information Maelstrom (today’s world of too much information) EVENTUAL SOLUTION AND ONLY REAL HOPE: The ABT

The string puller, talking about his prize pupil, our President.

Getting to Fully Know the ABT

Over the past decade I have written 12 books about the ABT as we have trained dozens of organizations (you can see the requisite stack of logos on our website) and thousands of folks in the “ABT (And, But, Therefore) Framework” (I still hate the term “framework” but had to call it something). And yet, it’s only in the past month I’ve been hit by a huge realization which is that IT’S ALL ABOUT SIGNAL-TO-NOISE.

AND, AND, AND (AAA) is noise. ABT (AND, BUT, THEREFORE) is signal.

In 2011 I knew in an instant when I first heard about the dynamic of these three words (AND, BUT, THEREFORE) that it was important. I heard the South Park co-creators mention it, then I tracked its origin back to a speech in 1986 by legendary screenwriting instructor Frank Daniel (from whom they probably learned it indirectly). BUT … its taken almost 15 years to see the full context of its importance.

Here’s why it is so important.

Narrative Is Everything

I’m no fan of Steve Bannon, BUT … at an analytical level, I’m pretty sure he understands American society today better than anyone. Better than all the communications professors, the news pundits, the bloggers, the influencers — on and on. Analytically, none of them hold a candle to him. Why?

Media production. He helped produce 18 Hollywood movies between 1991 and 2016. That changes the brain.

Dr. Michael Crichton (biomedical researcher-turned-filmmaker), as I argued in Ensia 3 years ago, also understood American society today better than anyone. Why? Same thing — media production. He directed 7 Hollywood movies and wrote the novel for another little movie called, Jurassic Park.

These characters have real world media production experience.

They’re not just drawing on media studies, media critiquing, or what they think they’ve learned from being interviewed by the media — all the standard things that cause academics and journalists to think they understand how society works — they don’t. It’s only through MAKING media that you can develop the VISCERAL (not CEREBRAL) grasp of how it works, and even then, you probably still don’t know. Why?

We Are a “Media-Driven” Society

We are not an “academic-driven society.” We are not a “democratic-driven society.” We are not definitely not an “intellectually-driven society.”

We are a MEDIA-DRIVEN SOCIETY as great thinkers like David Halberstam tried to make clear in monumental books like, The Powers That Be.

Narrative Is Truly Everything

And, if you look at the quote above from the “unsettling” interview David Brooks did with Steve Bannon last year in the New York Times, you see Bannon mention the same phrasing that hit me a few years ago. He says, “Everything is narrative,” I titled my 2019 book, Narrative is Everything.

It is.

It’s now out of control. Misinformation (= noise) is everywhere. We are in “The Information Maelstrom” that Marshall McLuhan predicted (and not surprisingly Bannon in that interview cited McLuhan in reference to Trump). Noise is now the enemy of society. Signal is the only hope.

AAA is noise. ABT is signal.

And THAT is why the ABT is so important.

#219) The NARRATIVE KNOCKDOWN 8: David Brooks, nearing narrative perfection?

What are the optimum scores for the 2 narrative metrics? For the AND Frequency it’s 2.5%. But for the Narrative Index? Good question. David Brooks looks pretty optimal for both scores.

THE OPTIMA: Everyone knows 2.5% is the optimum for the AF (AND Frequency). Could it be that 25 is the optimum for the NI (Narrative Index)?

2.5% and 25?

I’ve known for a long time that the AF (AND Frequency) has an optimal value of 2.5%. I learned it in the Stanford Literary Lab’s study of the annual reports of the World Bank. They, in turn, cited the Longman Grammar study of 1999.

But what about the NI (Narrative Index)?

We (Narrative Metrics Team members Matthew David, Liz Strauss, and I) have been studying the writings and speeches of a series of individuals over the past couple months. We’re increasingly thinking there might also be an optimal value for the NI.

“Goldilocks-ing”: Too much narrative content, too little, and juuuuust right

We’ve speculated on the possibility that when the NI score gets above 30 there might be a risk of entering into the realm of “overly-narrative.” This means the DHY form (Despite, However, Yet). Our friend Andy Reynolds of NCQA addressed this specifically in our ABT mini-symposium in June.

At first we thought the sky high scores of Jeremy Faust, MD and economist Paul Krugman were the mark of communication brilliance, but lately … we’ve been wondering if there might be such a thing as “TOO MANY BUTS.”

David Brooks looks like an optimal communicator

I’ve always been a fan of David Brooks in the NY Times. His arguments seem clear, compelling, well thought out and well structured. He’s our focus this week and sure enough, he scores a near-perfect AF of 2.6%.

He also scores a very respectable 25 for the NI. In fact, we’re thinking that might be the ideal score. Enough BUTs to keep the energy going, but not so many as to be “shouting” or providing too many narrative directions.

And thus, this becomes our current thinking. That each of the two metrics has its own optimum.

Just a thought for now.

#218) THE NARRATIVE KNOCKDOWN #7: The Story Continues, this week with Donald Trump, On and Off Script

Trump has two speaking modes: bland versus fiery. One is scripted (his day job), the other shoots from the hip, is borderline crazy, and inspires his base. The Narrative Metrics reveal all.

Hercules shouts about health issues, the Hulk holds court over economic policies, a couple of magazine editors speak rationally, a great columnist keeps her cool, a macho Health Secretary turns out to be a narrative weenie, and all the while, the two forms of President Trump are revealed by the Narrative Index of his speeches.

Trump: Unscripted barking versus scripted restraint

This is the next installment in our on-going quantitiatve analysis of the narrative strength of various communicators. If you’re not clear on our two narrative metrics you can go back to our first post in this series for an explanation.

So for this week, our focus is the two versions of Donald Trump when it comes to public speaking. This fundamental divide became evident during his first term as U.S. President (I wrote a series of blogposts back then as I was first developing the narrative metrics). There are two versions of him for public speaking as you can see in the graph.

You can see the divide in the two groups of speeches we analyzed just by looking at the labels for the speeches in the spreadsheet below. The UNSCRIPTED speeches were events like Coachella, CPAC, the Al Smith Dinner — all venues where everyone wants the entertainer version of Trump. The SCRIPTED speeches were all from the teleprompter — things like his State of the Union addresses, Inaugural Address, commencement speeches.

The unscripted, shooting from the hip version of Trump is loud, bellicose, braying, bragging, bullying and often a boor. That version averages over 30 for the Narrative Index — the highest average we’ve ever seen for a politician.

The other version is more “diplomatic” (though that term is a stretch for him). It is more restrained, averages below 10 (a “D” for a letter grade) and is probably controlled mostly by the writing of Stephen Miller and his other speech writers who craft the text that he reads off the teleprompter.

A Boor versus a Bore

This is what the Narrative Index shows, quantitatively. When he goes scripted, he gets boring. When he throws out the script, he becomes a boor who lights the place up. And by the way, his January 6 speech scored a 26. Right on-brand.

All of which shows QUANTITATIVELY what I’ve been saying for a decade: Trump Knows Narrative.

Far better than any Democrat. Which is why, like it or not, the news of his demise continues to be premature. He understands our media-driven mess of a society, far better than any scholar, pundit, or critic, with the possible one exception of Steve Bannon (which was what David Brooks found so unsettling about him).

#217) THE NARRATIVE KNOCKDOWN #5: RFK, Jr. is a Narrative Smudge

Robert Kennedy, Jr. may be fond of contrarian views but when we look at his narrative metrics he’s not arguing very powerfully. Why? Uncertainty is the enemy of narrative.

We now have Narrative Shouters, a Smirker, and a Wimp.

 

The singular narratives vs mixed messages

As we all know, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr is trying to do a makeover on American public health. But exactly which parts of it and exactly how much, tends to be unclear. Search his name with “mixed messages” and you’ll find stacks of articles with that in the title.

One of the fundamental requirements for powerful narrative structure is to know what is the story you’re seeking to tell. It’s not clear he’s always certain of that.

As a result, take a look at his Narrative Index. It’s a paltry 11.

He claims to have the singular message of MAHA (Make America Health Again) as stated in May in his first major report, but The Daily Beast and Washington Post quickly pointed out the report was riddled with inconsistencies and even fabricated material from A.I.

If you don’t know your story you’re not going to have strong metrics

The inconsistencies start with trying to argue for a reduced role of federal government at the same time that he’s recommending aggresive federal intervention in personal nutrition. He has consolidated more power in the new AHA (Administration for a Healthy America) with a top-down reorganization more centralized than anything in any previous administrations.

While at the same time trying to argue against big government? Seems like he’s saying, “We need big government to get rid of big government.”

The result is a confused agenda, confused messaging, and thus weak narrative structure.

Who’s afraid of the big bad RJK, Jr.

The point is he’s not a good communicator. Yes, he has Kennedy instant visual appeal and even some heft, but once he opens his mouth, it’s not adding up.

RFK, Jr. with the weak narrative metrics

For RFK, Jr. we opted for only articles and speeches over 1,000 words for which we could only find 10 (but that’s plenty).

#216) THE NARRATIVE KNOCKDOWN 4: Maureen Dowd appears to be “narrative normal”

What does the Narrative Index (NI) tell us? A lot. At least sometimes. We all know Maureen Dowd is a brilliant writer, but when it comes to narrative structure, she appears to be more restrained.

Smirkers versus shouters? This odd portrait of, “Tea and Tater Tots,” compliments of Chat GPT.

The deft voice of Maureen Dowd

Let’s start with the link to our KNOCKDOWN FORUM where you can share any thoughts, comments or suggestions (like “get stuffed” if you don’t like this particular post).

The numbers don’t lie: “A smirk not a shout”

Legendary New York Times columnist Maureen Dowd scores only a “B” for narrative structure with NI = 19. That’s not bad — it’s where just about all politicians score.

It’s not blazing, bellicose argumentation. But then I don’t think that is how anyone would characterize her style. She’s more understated and sly.

I asked Chat GPT to describe her style. Among several things it said was this:

Character-driven – Rather than focusing on policy or complex analysis, she zooms in on personalities. She portrays public figures almost like characters in a drama or satire, highlighting their quirks, hypocrisies, or vanity.

When I asked if she is “aggressive,” part of what it said was:

No, she’s not uniformly aggressive in the sense of being humorless or strident. Her power often lies in her underhanded jabs—a sharp line delivered with a smirk, not a shout. Her aggression is frequently couched in irony, playfulness, and theatrical flair, rather than blunt-force argumentation.

All of these replies are indeed consistent with a narrative index of 19. Particularly interesting is the line, “a smirk, not a shout.” Think about that line in relation to our narrative heavy weights (Krugman, Faust, 49 and 47, respectively).

Shouters versus smirkers. I like that. A lot.

Also, soak in the narrative beauty of her And Frequency, a near-perfect score AF = 2.48% (she really needs to work on that last 0.02%).

Argue over the interpretation (but not the data)

All we’re doing here is reporting the patterns we see in the two most important words for narrative structure (AND, BUT). We’re doing a reasonably systematic job with the analysis — usually reporting the average of 25 samples from a single venue, usually over 1,000 words for each essay.

You can’t argue the numbers, but when it comes to interpretation, what does it all mean?

That’s what we’re constantly working on. For this installment, I think we’ve identified the divide between smirkers versus shouters.

Could we be discerning a pattern? Might it be that we have a couple of shouters?